report

The Future Has Many Possible Forms: Who Decides Its Direction? 

Published in Privacy by

A ― A

Technology transforms our production processes, individual relationships, and the ways in which we come into contact with, perceive, and understand the world. In other words, it contributes to constructing the meaning we attribute to reality. 

The boundaries within which we can imagine possible futures, and the range of options through which future scenarios can take shape, are themselves shaped by decisions and choices. This reflection therefore aims to shed light on the relationship between technological development and the decision-making processes that define the boundaries within which it can take place. 

This relationship can be better understood by considering the tendency to perceive technological development as a neutral, objective, and linear process.

The presumed neutrality of technology

There is an established narrative within technical environments, which prevents us from fully recognising the relativity of some choices and the room for manoeuvre they leave open. It is the idea that “technology in itself is neutral; it depends on how it is used.” This narrative portrays technology as a neutral object: something that exists, that arrives, and that can be used subsequently in different ways – placing the ultimate responsibility on those who use it.

This argument is both biased and partial. It is biased because it starts from a conflation between science, knowledge, and technology. Knowledge may be considered neutral in certain respects; technology cannot. It is partial because it captures only one stage of the technological process: the final stage. It starts from the point at which we already have the technology. In doing so, it diverts attention from:

  • the many choices and points at which possibilities diverge that take place upstream, before a technological artefact takes shape;
  • who has the power to decide one direction rather than another: the decisions that lead to its development, the alternatives that are not pursued, the actors who participate in these choices, and those who remain excluded;
  • the possible margins for action and the alternatives that other actors should legitimately be able to consider, including questions of governance and alternative trajectories.

Subjectivity therefore does not intervene only at the end, when a technology and its use are evaluated. It intervenes much earlier, in deciding which futures are worth exploring through research and innovation.

Technology does not emerge in a neutral space. It is an artefact conceived within a specific cultural context, influenced by political priorities, economic strategies, social values, stereotypes, interests, and the perspectives of those involved in its design.

The question, therefore, is not only: who decides how a technology is used? It is also: who decides which technology to develop, to address which problem, and according to which priorities? Whose priorities will guide the visions of the future that are pursued? Whose vision will find a place in the scenarios towards which we strive?

Research and innovation: the space in which the future is designed

The space in which these questions can be explored is that of research and innovation (R&I). 

R&I constitute the space within which the range of our future possibilities is opened up and projected forward. It is a space in which knowledge is explored, scenarios are imagined, and capabilities are developed that can concretely change the world in which we live. But R&I is also an area of political and economic choices and, therefore, a space in which the specific meaning of progress is defined through those choices, while the broader range of possibilities is progressively narrowed.

Consider the shape of our landscapes, the structure of our cities, the ways in which we move, what we eat, the materials that surround us, how healthcare systems function, and how we are cured. Decisions made today in these areas contribute to defining the material and relational conditions of our future.

The space of R&I consists of two stages that are often treated together as an inseparable pair, but that bring important differences. Research and innovation are temporal stages, but they are also different epistemic domains, guided by different criteria.

Research is the space of exploration, discovery and opening. It expands knowledge and opens up possibilities. Innovation is the space of application. It selects, directs, and transforms some of these possibilities into actual products, services, infrastructures, and organisational models.

The two therefore perform different functions in shaping technological trajectories. Research tends to expand the space of what can be known and what may become possible; innovation necessarily involves a process of selection, as some possibilities are pursued, developed, and brought into application while others are not.

In the words of Geoffrey Nicholson: “Research is the transformation of money into knowledge. Innovation is the transformation of knowledge into money.” This statement, which may appear reductive or like a catchy slogan, nevertheless helps explain why neither of these processes is entirely neutral.

Research agendas are themselves shaped by political and institutional priorities, funding structures, available resources, and the interests and perspectives of those involved. What is researched, what receives support, and which lines of inquiry are considered worth investigating, which hypotheses deserve resources, are all the result of choices. 

Innovation makes this process of selection even more explicit, as it involves directing knowledge towards particular forms of value creation and application. In this sense, innovation more visibly embodies particular interests, priorities, and visions of what is worth pursuing.

Behind what is presented to us as objective lies a long decision-making process that means technological development does not follow neutral, necessary, or univocal trajectories. Someone decides which possibilities will have a chance of becoming reality, and at every stage the range of some possibilities will expand— while that of others will narrow.

When new technical possibilities are discovered, some are assessed and supported while others are not; some are developed while others are not; among different hypotheses of feasibility, some are pursued and brought to application, while others are not. The question, then, is to understand which dynamics influence these choices.

Who decides what, and through which parameters?

We would be mistaken to assume that most choices are made with full awareness, on the part of those making them, of the actual range of possibilities available. These decisions are not necessarily conscious, intentional, or the result of an explicit strategy. They are often influenced by a deeply internalised cultural system that defines what appears important, rational, feasible, and worthy of investment.

Also, it is important to stress that we are not referring, here to one decision-maker; we are speaking instead about a decision-making system, composed by funding structures, policy priorities, industrial interests, corporate market strategies, and – most importantly – cultural frames. Across such a system, choices and disjunction of possibilities emerge through the interaction of two levels.

The first level concerns the decision-making frames that shape decision processes: the criteria used to make choices—what is considered relevant, a priority, important, or appropriate; the thresholds of acceptability; the perception and hierarchy of risks; the recognition of a problem; and the motivations that orient choices.

The second level is deeper. It concerns the system through which relative value is attributed to the elements of the first level. This is the level of value orientations: what is considered valuable; what is given priority when values conflict; what is considered desirable to pursue and realise; what is considered worth protecting; and what is considered an acceptable cost or trade-off.

Culture influences priorities, motivations, decision-making criteria, and the hierarchy of risks. It influences what we define as a problem and what we fail to recognise as one; which challenges we choose to take on and which we instead label as “impossible”. It influences what we consider important and worthy of priority—and this, in turn, shapes the hierarchy according to which knowledge and solutions are funded.

Consider, for example, the fact that in some domains the word impossible is rarely contemplated (the war and defense sector is sadly always at the forefront of innovation). Other domains, by contrast, tend to be tagged or perceived as “impossible”, or at least idealistic – let’s think about the transition towards economic paradigms in which environmental protection and value generation are no longer understood as inherently conflicting objectives.

Culture also influences the threshold of what we consider acceptable or, conversely, unacceptable. On this basis, specific forms of regulation are established, as illustrated by current debates and regulatory approaches concerning AI or CO₂ emissions.

Finally, and no less importantly, culture influences the way in which we decide to address a problem. Addressing the causes of a problem is one thing; looking instead for quick fixes that allow us to manage its consequences without actually resolving it is another. Climate change provides a clear example: rather than addressing the underlying paradigm that produces the problem, the problem can be reframed in terms of “climate mitigation”.

Strategic decisions and technological artefacts, therefore, embody a particular vision of the world.

Research and innovation priorities always reflect, at least in part, what a society considers important. And if the experiences from which these priorities are defined are socially partial, the future that becomes technically explorable risks being partial as well.

Conclusion

Technological development is often presented as natural, inevitable, unambiguous, and necessary. The distinction between what can be done—technological feasibility—and what is decided to be pursued is thereby obscured, making particular technological trajectories appear as objective responses to what is possible rather than as the outcome of choices. 

Yet, technology does not produce a single inevitable future. Choices determine which possibilities are pursued, prioritised, actualized, or left aside. These choices are not made in a vacuum: they are shaped by assumptions, interests, power relations and value orientations that make some futures more visible, desirable, or legitimate than others.

This dimension of technological development remains largely invisible to the people who encounter its outcomes in everyday life. The result is a democratic gap: technologies can shape the conditions in which society lives, but the orientations underlying the choices are not equally visible or open to public scrutiny. 

The question, then, is not simply what technology can do for us, but whose priorities, values, interests, and visions are reflected in what technology becomes—and whose are not. If technology reflects only particular priorities and a particular vision of reality then the world we inhabit is not the only possible one. The social stakes of becoming aware of these processes are significant. 

Service involved

Assessment of technology impact on privacy
We help our clients and partners to achieve their business goals while addressing ethics, privacy and cybersecurity concerns in a manner that prevents conflicts, sanctions and loss of money derived by the lack of ethical and legal compliance to national and European applicable regulations. All information technologies must respect human fundamental rights and ensure the rights of people in relation to the protection of their private life, personal data and freedom. The new EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) that replaced the Data Protection Directive in all EU member states on May 2018 introduces many new obligations for companies and a comprehensive set of rights for data subjects, including the right to an effective judicial remedy against a controller or a processor and the right to compensation. Therefore, in addition to being at the receiving end of an enforcement action, data controllers and processors may be subject to court proceedings and have to pay compensation to data subjects for their infringements of the GDPR. Our approach to help our clients to avoid this kind of issues consists of a holistic service composed by the following main components: providing a Data Protection Officer to drive the organization’s legal compliance action; mapping the data processed by the organisation to measure its impact on the ethical principles and legal framework; assessing the cybersecurity mechanisms used by the organisation technologies; conducting an impact assessment for all data processing mechanisms identifying ethical, legal and security risks; making recommendations for the implementation of the organisational and technical means to be compliant with the legal framework while ensuring data confidentiality (preserving authorized restrictions on information access and disclosure, including personal privacy and proprietary information protection), integrity (assurance that data is not modified or deleted in an unauthorized and undetected manner), availability (ensuring there’s timely and reliable access to and use of information) and accountability (supporting non‐repudiation, deterrence, fault isolation, intrusion detection and prevention, and after‐action recovery and legal action).
Ethics assessment of technology
We help our clients and partners in the process of critical analysis to examine the effects that the introduction and use of a technology may have on human rights, society, and the environment. This is a complex process that requires a systematic view and consideration of how technology might affect people and society at large in the short and long term. The ethical impact of technology is therefore crucial when developing and deploying new technologies, in order to mitigate the negative effects and maximise the benefits, and to enable developers, organisations and policy makers to make informed decisions. In this assessment, we assist our clients and partners to consider all relevant factors; there are several methodologies and approaches used to assess the ethical impact of technologies, including:
  • Privacy impact analysis: this type of analysis assesses the effects of technology on the privacy of individuals and their personal information. It considers the risks of monitoring and tracking, the consequences of possible data breaches and the security measures needed to protect users' privacy.
  • Social impact assessment: this type of analysis evaluates the effects of technology on society and the economy in general, considering impacts on unemployment, social equality, access to education and health, quality of life and environmental sustainability.
  • Ethical impact assessment: This type of analysis assesses the effects of technology on society's morals and values, considering impacts on social justice, accountability, transparency, human dignity and individual freedom.
  • Life cycle analysis: This type of analysis assesses the environmental impacts of technology throughout its life cycle, from production to use and end of life.
Ethical impact assessment of technologies therefore requires a multidisciplinary evaluation involving technology experts, ethics experts, legal experts, environmental experts and other stakeholders.
Social acceptance of technologies assessment
Connected, disruptive technologies permeate all aspects of our daily lives and pose challenges to the real foundation of human rights, such as the right to privacy or the freedom of speech. One could say that human values such as trust, accountability, and dignity are mutually influenced by the social acceptance of technologies. We support our clients to conceive a novel way of aligning the thus-far divergent concepts of sustainability, ethics impact, and technological innovation. By combining these three concepts, we respond to the need of a socially responsible innovation ecosystem by developing a tailored methodology for assessing users’/citizens’ social acceptance of technologies, a fundamental driver for technology market adoption. Our social acceptance framework includes six fundamental dimensions over which social acceptability (i.e. perception, motivation, trust, awareness, capacity enabling, and accountability) is measured and assessed through a two-step approach based on an online Sentiment Analysis (SA) – to create structured and actionable knowledge from the web – and the engagement of our client’s stakeholders (e.g. relevant target groups, associations of citizens, domain operators, decision makers, etc.) for the technology co-creation and communication regarding its social acceptance.
Responsible Research & Innovation
We love discovering and staying on top of new research to continuously advance our knowledge and to transform it into responsible innovation, taking into account effects and potential impacts on ethics, privacy and data protection. We help national and international partners to handle ethical, legal and cybersecurity concerns on both the research process and the project outcomes, through the legal support for the involvement of human beings in the research activity, the analysis of the national and regional legal framework applicable to the implementing technology and the recommendations for the secure and compliant development of technology. We are a multidisciplinary team that promotes the inclusion of legal and ethical concerns in the design of the technology, researching and producing new knowledge and best practices towards making a conscious and transparent adoption of technology.
External Ethics Advisors

We believe that ethics is not an afterthought, but a lens through which to view the entire journey of creating innovative solutions. That’s why we offer our expertise as External Ethics Advisors, supporting projects and organizations in managing ethics boards, reviewing project outputs, and assessing ethical and legal compliance—always with careful attention to the specific context.

We work with a range of clients and partners and have built a strong reputation in this field, recognized by the European Commission. Our approach is authoritative yet approachable, technically sound yet rooted in dialogue.

We use interactive workshops, guidelines, informational materials, and practical tools (such as helpdesks and tailored templates) not just as supports, but as core elements of our advisory and evaluation process. These tools help raise awareness, foster discussion, and build a shared, robust ethical approach with our partners and clients.

We intervene both during the development phase (to ensure the project is carried out in line with ethical principles and applicable regulations) and in the evaluation of final outputs (to verify their consistency with those same principles). We operate as internal consultants within consortia and project teams, as well as external experts and independent evaluators.

What sets us apart is the ongoing, direct dialogue we maintain with those we work with: we tailor our analyses, recommendations, and tools to the real needs of each project. We work side by side with clients and partners, with a critical but constructive perspective, to support them through every stage of their innovation journey.